1. The scale of payment-card fraud
Card fraud is enormous and concentrated in the US market.
$33.41B
Global payment-card fraud losses in 2024 — down 1.2% from 2023.
41.87%
Of global card-fraud losses fall on the US — which is only 26.31% of worldwide card volume.
$407.6B
Projected cumulative global card-fraud losses over 2025–2034 — rising to $41.06B a year by 2030 and $48.50B by 2034.
2. Chargebacks by volume, value, and cost
From Mastercard's own 2025 State of Chargebacks report (research by Datos Insights).
261M → 324M
Global chargeback volume, 2025 to 2028 — a projected 24% rise.
$33.79B → $41.69B
Total global chargeback value, 2025 to 2028 — a 23% increase.
$110
Average chargeback value for US merchants — and over half report an average above $100.
$77 / $69
Average chargeback value for digital-goods ($77) and subscription-service ($69) merchants.
up to 2.5×
What a single chargeback can cost relative to the transaction value once fees and operational costs are counted — at a 5% margin, it takes ~17 sales to recover one.
Source: Mastercard estimate (2025), as reported by
ChargebackHelp, 2025
3. Card-not-present fraud — the online exposure
Where subscription and digital businesses actually live.
73%
CNP fraud's share of card-payment fraud loss (up from 57% in 2019) — about $9.49B.
$362B
Projected cumulative online payment-fraud losses, 2023–2028 — including $91B in 2028 alone.
4. Friendly fraud — the chargeback most merchants can't stop
First-party misuse is the dominant, fastest-growing category for subscription apps.
~45% / 72%
Share of merchants' chargeback volume that is fraudulent (~45%) — while issuers classify 72% of disputes as fraudulent.
up to 70%
Of all credit-card fraud that card networks trace to chargeback misuse — i.e. friendly fraud.
+18%
Average reported rise in friendly fraud over three years — reported by nearly three-quarters of surveyed merchants.
5. Why fighting chargebacks rarely pays off
The case for prevention and interception over representment.
52% → 18%
Merchants represent (fight) ~52% of chargeback cases but win only ~18% of them.
~20%
Average net recovery rate — the share of the disputed amount merchants actually get back.
6. The subscription angle — involuntary churn
For recurring-billing businesses, failed payments are a fraud-adjacent revenue leak.
20–40%
Of total subscription churn is involuntary — driven by failed or declined recurring payments, not customers choosing to leave.
7. Broader US fraud context
Government data on the fraud environment merchants operate in.
$12.5B
US consumer fraud losses reported to the FTC in 2024 — up more than $2B (~25%) year over year.
$16.6B
Total losses reported to the FBI's IC3 in 2024 — a 33% jump over 2023.
449,032
Credit-card identity-theft reports to the FTC — the #1 identity-theft type in 2024.
$785M
Losses from non-payment / non-delivery complaints to IC3 — across 49,572 complaints in 2024.
What the numbers say for subscription apps
Read together, the data points one direction. Chargebacks are growing in both volume (+24% to 2028) and value (+23%), the majority of them are now some flavour of fraud — and most of that is friendly fraud, the kind no pre-authorization fraud filter can catch. Meanwhile, fighting chargebacks after the fact wins only ~18% of the time. For a subscription business, the cheap money is upstream: prevent the disputable charge, or intercept the dispute before it posts.
That's also why the per-chargeback cost matters more than the headline number. At an average of ~$69 for a subscription charge but "up to 2.5×" the transaction value in true cost — plus the ~17-sale recovery math at thin margins — a rising ratio quietly compounds long before it trips a monitoring program. You can put your own figure on it with the chargeback cost calculator, and model your VAMP/ECM ratio with the payment risk calculator.
Frequently asked questions
- How much money is lost to payment-card fraud each year?
- Global payment-card fraud losses were $33.41B in 2024 (down 1.2%), per the Nilson Report — with the US bearing 41.87% of losses on just 26.31% of card volume. Nilson projects $407.6B cumulative over 2025–2034.
- How much does a chargeback cost a merchant?
- US merchants average ~$110 per chargeback ($77 digital goods, $69 subscriptions) per Mastercard's 2025 report, and Mastercard estimates the true cost at up to 2.5× the transaction value — about 17 sales to recover one at a 5% margin.
- What percentage of chargebacks are friendly fraud?
- About 45% of merchants' chargeback volume is fraudulent (issuers say 72% of disputes), per Mastercard; networks trace up to 70% of card fraud to chargeback misuse, which merchants report up 18% over three years.
- Do merchants win chargeback disputes?
- Rarely. Merchants represent ~52% of cases but win only ~18%, recovering ~20% of the disputed amount on average (Chargebacks911 2024 Field Report).
- How big is card-not-present fraud?
- CNP is ~73% of card-payment fraud loss (~$9.49B) per eMarketer; Juniper Research projected $362B cumulative online fraud over 2023–2028 ($91B in 2028).
Sources & method. Every figure on this page was taken from, and links to, a named source — primary where possible: the
FBI IC3 and
FTC annual reports, the
Nilson Report,
Juniper Research, and
Mastercard's State of Chargebacks report (research by Datos Insights). A handful of figures come from industry research (eMarketer, the Chargebacks911 Field Report, Recurly) that attribute to named studies. Figures that couldn't be confirmed at their source were left out. For the card-network
thresholds (Visa VAMP, Mastercard ECM), see the maintained
program-thresholds reference rather than this page.
When the numbers get personal
I've taken a subscription app from 13% chargebacks to under 1% — and out of Mastercard ECM.
If your own ratio is trending the wrong way, the 90-day Chargeback Rescue program rebuilds your Stripe Radar rules, sets up Ethoca/Verifi dispute interception, and produces the compliance documentation processors accept.
Book a Free Consultation →
See the Chargeback Rescue program → · Read the ECM exit guide →